Clint Gutherson’s ongoing confrontations with NRL referees have prompted Parramatta Eels legend Brett Kenny to suggest that the fullback should be replaced as captain by halfback Mitchell Moses. Kenny expressed concerns that Gutherson’s frequent interactions with referees might be detrimental to the team’s performance, advocating for Moses to take on the leadership role. ([Yahoo Sports][1])
Gutherson’s tenure as captain has been marked by passionate defense of his team, but recent incidents have raised questions about his approach. In a match against the Canterbury Bulldogs, Gutherson engaged in a heated exchange with referee Peter Gough over a controversial try, leading to a reprimand where Gough advised him to “be better as captain.” Additionally, Gutherson faced criticism for attempting to deceive the referee into awarding a penalty during a game against the Wests Tigers, an act that many considered unsportsmanlike. ([FOX SPORTS][2], [Yahoo Sports][3])
Despite these controversies, Gutherson remains a key player for the Eels, known for his defensive capabilities and work ethic. However, with the team’s evolving dynamics and the emergence of new talent, the discussion about leadership within the squad has intensified. Mitchell Moses, who has demonstrated significant growth, particularly during State of Origin, is seen by some as a potential successor to Gutherson as captain. ([FOX SPORTS][4])
The debate over the captaincy reflects broader considerations about team leadership and the qualities that best serve a club’s success. While Gutherson’s passion is undeniable, the question remains whether his approach aligns with the evolving needs of the Eels. As the team looks to the future, the decision regarding the captaincy will be pivotal in shaping its direction.
Parramatta Eels captain Clint Gutherson’s ongoing confrontations with NRL referees have sparked significant debate, culminating in calls from club legend Brett Kenny for a leadership change. Kenny suggests that Mitchell Moses should replace Gutherson as captain, citing concerns over Gutherson’s interactions with officials and his on-field demeanor.([Yahoo Sports][1])
—
### The Catalyst: Referee Disputes
Gutherson’s recent behavior on the field has drawn criticism from various quarters. In a match against the Canterbury Bulldogs, he engaged in a heated exchange with referee Peter Gough over a contentious try. Gough admonished Gutherson, stating, “Regardless of your opinion as captain, do not speak to me like that when you ask me for the answer. That is not acceptable. You need to be better as a captain.” ([FOX SPORTS][2], [Yahoo Sports][3])
Further incidents have added to the scrutiny. In a game against the Wests Tigers, Gutherson was seen attempting to deceive the referee by initiating contact with an opponent and then appealing for a penalty. The referee, however, did not award the penalty, and the incident drew widespread criticism on social media. ([Yahoo Sports][4])
—
### Brett Kenny’s Perspective
Brett Kenny, a four-time premiership winner with the Eels, has expressed concerns over Gutherson’s conduct. Appearing on the Matty Johns Show, Kenny stated, “Watching Gutho the last few weeks, he seems to be doing a lot of talking with the referees and I’m thinking you’re going to put them offside in the end.” ([Yahoo Sports][4], [Yahoo Sports][1])
Kenny believes that Gutherson’s actions could be detrimental to the team’s dynamics and that it’s time for a change in leadership. He advocates for Mitchell Moses to take over the captaincy, emphasizing Moses’s growth and leadership qualities. “I would look now to giving (Moses) the captaincy next year,” Kenny added. ([Yahoo Sports][1])
—
### Mitchell Moses: A Rising Leader
Mitchell Moses’s leadership potential has been evident, particularly during State of Origin matches where he stepped up in the absence of key players. His ability to manage the game and lead by example has not gone unnoticed. According to reports, there is a sentiment within the Eels camp that Moses could be the future leader of the team. “Not just a new coach, let’s give Moses the reins,” one insider noted. ([FOX SPORTS][5])
Moses’s on-field performance and maturity have positioned him as a strong candidate for the captaincy. His leadership qualities were particularly highlighted during the 2024 State of Origin series, where he effectively managed the team in the absence of the regular captain. ([FOX SPORTS][5])
—
### The Future of Gutherson and the Eels
Despite the calls for a change in leadership, Clint Gutherson remains under contract with the Eels until the end of the 2025 season. His commitment to the team is evident, and he has expressed willingness to adapt to whatever role best serves the club’s interests. This adaptability could see him transition to a different position, such as the centres, to accommodate emerging talents like Blaize Talagi. ([FOX SPORTS][5])
The Eels’ management faces a delicate situation. Balancing the team’s immediate needs with long-term goals will be crucial. While leadership changes are significant, they also present opportunities for growth and development within the squad.
—
### Conclusion
Clint Gutherson’s interactions with referees have sparked a broader conversation about leadership within the Parramatta Eels. Brett Kenny’s call for Mitchell Moses to assume the captaincy reflects a desire for a shift in team dynamics. As the Eels navigate this period of reflection and potential change, the focus will be on fostering a cohesive environment that prioritizes the team’s success both on and off the field.
Leave a Reply